July 25, 2025

What Most Companies Get Wrong About Health Insurance Renewal

The Healthee Brief

July 25, 2025

Renewing your organization’s health insurance offerings should not be seen as merely an annual chore; it is essential to your benefits strategy. Yet too often, it gets the checkbox treatment.

Behind the scenes, real leverage comes from analyzing plan performance. It involves understanding how employees use healthcare. This helps in making data-driven choices that go beyond just premium costs. Smart HR teams know that carrier negotiations are just one part of the story. Renewal season is the moment to align your benefits with your people’s real-world needs.

Start early, and you can outpace rising healthcare costs, avoid last-minute decisions, and build trust across your organization. Wait too long, and you risk misalignment, miscommunication, and missed opportunities.

Need help planning? Check out our open enrollment strategy guide.

The Deductible Reset Dilemma

Here’s a major blind spot in the employee benefits renewal process: most employees don’t understand what a deductible reset means, let alone the countless other benefits terms to nail down. 

Many are surprised when January 1 hits and their out-of-pocket costs are back to square one. That’s a communication failure, not a comprehension one.

The best HR teams plan ahead. They educate employees about how resets impact their wallets, provide timelines for expected changes, and use proactive tools to build awareness, long before open enrollment kicks off.

 

Factor in passive enrollment

One factor that often adds to the confusion? Passive enrollment. When employees don’t actively select new benefits during renewal, they’re less likely to mentally prepare for the deductible reset that’s coming. Without clear reminders or a reason to re-engage, the January 1 surprise hits harder. Proactive communication, whether employees are actively enrolling or not, is key to making sure no one feels caught off guard.

Benefits Education Is the Difference Between Confusion and Confidence

If you’re only educating employees during Q4, you’re already behind. Year-round benefits education turns confused questions into confident decisions. Plus, it reduces the HR inbox traffic jam during open enrollment.

The key is making information available before employees even think to ask. With Healthee’s AI-powered assistant, Zoe, employees get real-time answers to questions about their specific health plan, pulled straight from company plan documents.

No guide-flipping. No bottlenecks. Just the facts, fast.

Build an Employee-First Health Insurance Renewal Strategy

Too many companies default to the “cheapest option wins” mindset. But a strong health insurance renewal process starts by asking: How are employees actually using healthcare?

When you use real-time utilization data and AI-powered insights, you can align your plans with what matters; like provider preferences, treatment patterns, and benefits gaps.

Healthee equips employees with cost transparency and in-network provider search tools, so they can make smarter, more personalized healthcare choices. Better for them. Smarter for your bottom line.

Tips to Communicate Plan Renewals with Clarity and Impact

Timing matters when it comes to open enrollment communication plans. Messaging matters even more. Use this sample timeline to guide your employee communication:

  • 6-8 weeks before OE: Announce changes and what’s staying the same
  • 4 weeks before OE: Share FAQs and deductible reset reminders
  • 2 weeks before OE: Provide side-by-side plan comparisons
  • 1 week before OE: Offer a final Q&A session (or encourage use of tools like Zoe)

Layer in digital channels, like SMS, social posts, or even better, Healthee Connect, to make information stick. When benefits feel easy to access, they start to feel like a perk, not a puzzle. And that shift reinforces your employer brand in a big way.

 

Plan renewal communication sample

Need help crafting your benefits messaging? Here’s a short sample email you can adapt and send to employees during open enrollment season. It’s designed to raise awareness about plan renewals, deductible resets, and available resources.

 

Subject line: What’s Changing in Your 2025 Benefits Plan?
Preview text: Plan renewals are coming, here’s what to know.

Hi [First name],

The new year means your benefits plan renews—and your deductible resets. Now’s the time to get clear on what’s changing and what’s staying the same.

Check out your current plan, compare options, and get answers to your deductible questions using [Zoe/Healthee support].

Want help navigating your options? We’ve got you.

[Explore Your Benefits] ← CTA button

– [Your HR Team Name]

Renew your Confidence in Open Enrollment Season

Health insurance renewal season doesn’t have to feel like a fire drill. With the right mix of early planning, deductible reset education, and employee-first strategies, open enrollment can become a moment of clarity and confidence, not chaos. Now, enjoy the peace of mind. 

Book a Demo

Book a Demo